Friday, September 12, 2008

Congressional testimony on NIH Public Access repeal effort

The House Judiciary Committee held hearings today on the newly introduced "Fair Copyright and Research Works Act (H.R. 6845)," which is a publisher-promoted effort to repeal the NIH Public Access Policy

Peter Suber's Open Access News discusses the hearings here and here. Karen Rustad at Little Green River has a great post about the hearing. 

I'm still reading and watching the testimony from the good guys: NIH Director Elias Zerhouni and SPARC's Heather Joseph, and the bad guys: GWU Law Professor Ralph Oman and the APS's Marty Frank. I'll have more to say (and if the video is good, maybe some attack ads) later. 

Now I disagree with Marty Frank on almost everything: he's short-sighted, often misleading and places the interests of his journal over the broader scientific good. However, I understand why he was invited to testify - he has become the chief spokesman (some would say apologist) for the anti-open access publishers. 

But I have to say when I saw the list of witnesses, my first reaction was "Who the hell is Ralph Oman?" OK, I'm not a copyright lawyer, and maybe he's well-known in those circles. But as far as I can tell he's never been interested in science publishing. 

So, of course, I googled him. And here's the top hit. A list of campaign contributions he's made. These lists are fascinating. Oman is clearly no Democrat. He gave money to Bill Frist, Henry Hyde and even Katherine Harris when she ran for Congress!! So it's curious that he also gave $500 to John Conyers, head of the House Judiciary Committee who is holding this hearing. Hmm. I wonder why he was invited.... Are our representatives really this cheap?

2 comments:

Anonymous said...

At least Wow Gold for now.then
cheapest wow goldwas one whom Buy Wow GoldMannoroth couldcheap wow gold especially not touch.buy cheap wow gold With the death of the queen?s advisor, Lordbuy world of warcraft gold
Xavius, the WOW FAQcaptain had become wow gold her liaison. Whenever the glorious Azshara opted WOW US not to gift those wow gold cheap working in the
chamber with wow gold news her magnificent presence,
wow gold about the guard captain took her place.
my site is :http://www.game4power.com.


Life is hard. cheapest wow gold We should not give up hope. By the time we have given wow gold cheap up, we are finished. Chances are always
wow gold news there. We have to
wow power leveling grab every single opportunity to help..., to
world of warcraft love and to serve. To live our life wow tips happier, full of joy, we have
cheap wow gold to set our goal and even dream big. If we choose the shortest path warhammer goldin life, we will never learn. To be or not to be, we have to be somebody. The fastest way to gain love is to love others first!Do not hide your talent, WOW GOID your knowledge and yourwow items beautiful heart. Go for your dream and live for it.[http://www.wowgoldone.com]

Anonymous said...

你的文章給我力量!感謝您!!!............................................................